Underfloor heating in a renovation: water vs electric
Underfloor heating in a renovation: water vs electric, running costs and compatibility
Imagine waking up on a cold winter morning, putting your bare feet on the tiles and feeling a pleasantly warm floor. No draughts blowing dusty air that dries out your eyes, and no traditional radiators taking up wall space you would rather use for furniture. That is the great comfort of modern invisible heating [that is, underfloor heating]. But when you plan a home renovation, choosing between hot-water pipes and thin electric mats under the floor is rarely straightforward for an owner without experience. Is it better to break up the old concrete or to lay ultra-thin mats on the existing base? There is no single standard answer. Changing a small bathroom does not call for the same technical approach as a complete renovation of the whole home carried out at the same time. We look at running costs, build-up depths and compatibility so you can decide correctly and save a good amount on your future energy bills.
Key points of the comparison
- Running costs: Water circuits with aerothermal heating can cut energy demand by up to seventy per cent.
- Build-up: Electric mats add only millimetres. Water systems need the floor raised by three to eight centimetres.
- Cost: Electric is cheap to start with, although which part of a renovation costs the most shows that hydronic systems pay back quickly.
- Materials: Porcelain and ceramic tiles transfer heat exceptionally well.
- Speed: Electric mats warm specific rooms within a few minutes.
Water underfloor heating: how it works and why aerothermal suits it so well
To understand this method, picture a network of flexible plastic pipes laid continuously across the whole floor area. Warm water flows through them, usually at between 35°C and 45°C. That is a low temperature compared with the 75°C that traditional metal radiators need. Because the system needs far less energy to produce that heat, the saving is excellent from the very first week of winter use.
This is where the ideal combination for this decade comes in: aerothermal heating. We suggest reading up on what aerothermal is to understand its impressive heat-pump efficiency. When you combine these water pipes with a modern heat pump, you get one of the most efficient and eco-friendly home heating systems available today. The big drawback of water in a renovation, however, is its physical build-up. It requires insulation panels, cross-linked polyethylene pipes and a self-levelling mortar screed of at least about five centimetres. This extra concrete layer not only adds considerable weight to the old floor slabs of residential buildings, it also noticeably reduces the usable height of the home. You may need to cut down internal door frames, raise the electrical sockets and adjust the ceiling light points. For that reason, planning each technical stage carefully with your installers is crucial, to avoid serious height problems and to keep the overall execution fees under control.
Electric underfloor heating: the quick option without screeds
Compared with water manifolds and pipework, the electric system stands out for its material simplicity. It consists of very thin mats with a heating wire built in, which warms up when it receives current. There are also ultra-thin carbon films that can be laid dry directly under wood parquet or floating timber floors.
Its great advantage is its thickness of just a few millimetres, which allows it to be embedded in the tile adhesive under the stoneware without pouring heavy screeds. It puts no extra load on old floor slabs and does not require deep demolition, saving time and masonry costs. In fact, if you want to speed up the works, looking at options to change the floor without major works in Barcelona is an ideal resource.
Just remember that the system will push up your consumption if you heat large rooms, and you may need to update the certificate for your home electrical installation: full guide to the fuse board, circuits, certificate and regulations because of the contracted power.
Real running costs: which one will cost you a small fortune by the end of the month?
Let's tackle the eternal financial question for the end user. A common mistake in a renovation is to look only at the price of the initial materials and assume that all radiant emitters work the same way. Electric cables have a direct performance coefficient of one to one. That means every kilowatt of electricity used turns into exactly one kilowatt of heat in the room. There are no losses, but there is no multiplied gain either.
Heat pumps, on the other hand, achieve performance coefficients of between four and five in mild climates. In other words, they use one kilowatt of electricity to draw free energy from the outside air and deliver up to five kilowatts of heat into your water pipes. The result is clear: heating with warm water can use up to eighty per cent less electricity each month than direct resistance heating. Although the initial investment in aerothermal equipment can be painful for the budget, it pays off quickly if you live in the home regularly. This not only eases recurring costs, it also significantly increases the market value of the property when you later obtain the official energy efficiency certificate showing the jump in consumption category for your home. So work through the real comfort needs of your household with a calculator and technical advice before you sign any final works quote or buy any climate-control equipment.
Floor compatibility and technical build-up
Materials react very differently to constant radiant heat. When you plan a new floor layout in your home, choosing the right surface finish will determine the real heating performance of the home. We always look for dense finishes. Here, porcelain stoneware and traditional ceramic tiles are the clear winners. They absorb the heat emitted quickly and distribute it remarkably evenly through each room by radiation. If you want ideas for durable finishes, see the comparison of which floor to choose: porcelain, parquet, microcement and vinyl compared to combine durability with the best comfort.
What if you are a dedicated fan of natural wood or laminate floors? They can be used, but they must be installed to strict standards. Choose multilayer hardwood boards of low thickness that are certified by the manufacturer as thermally compatible. It is essential to bond the pieces firmly to the concrete screed using polymer conductive adhesives, and to avoid floating installations, which create highly insulating air gaps. Microcement also heats up quickly, because its final application layer is very thin. Always check with an experienced technician or applicator you trust before curing, gradually switching on and stabilising the base screed before the final covering goes down. This careful approach will help make sure the finished smooth surfaces do not develop unsightly cracks caused by temperature changes over the cold winter months.
Detailed comparison table: water vs electric
To simplify your decision and make your investment clearer, we summarise the two approaches side by side in the technical table for the renovation:
| Variable | Water system | Electric system |
|---|---|---|
| Build-up depth required | Needs between 3 and 8 centimetres of depth to house the insulation board and the dense screed. | Does not exceed 1.5 centimetres in total, installed directly embedded in the tile adhesive. |
| Initial investment required | Considerable. Requires a modern heat pump or boiler and a complex installation of adjustable manifolds in the service rooms. | Very low and affordable. The cost of the mats and separate thermostats is minimal and quick to install. |
| Monthly running costs | Very low, thanks to the high thermodynamic efficiency of current aerothermal systems. | Considerably high if used as the main heating, because direct electric heat has no multiplier effect. |
| Speed of warming up | High inertia. Takes between twelve and twenty-four hours to stabilise the temperature from fully off. | Very low inertia. Gives a feeling of comfort in the rooms just one hour after switching on each day. |
| Recommended use | Full renovations where underfloor heating is the main daily heating. See our guide to aerothermal and climate control in a renovation. | Small or damp areas used briefly, such as bathroom floors or occasional kitchen spots. |
Practical scenarios in flat renovations: when does each option make sense?
To avoid falling into the theoretical traps of sales brochures, let's get down to the reality of the site. Imagine you have an old flat in a century-old Barcelona building. In these buildings the ceilings are magnificent, but the timber beam floors can show structural weakness and cannot take heavy loads from tonnes of wet mortar. Unless you are prepared to pay the extra for a dry hydronic system (with no self-levelling screed), your best option in the bathroom will be a quick electric mat, leaving the living room heated by a conventional wall-mounted heat pump.
By contrast, if you are in the middle of a full renovation of a detached or modern house with a reinforced concrete slab, opting for electric cables in every room is simply a mistake you will pay for in your monthly electricity bill as soon as the cold sets in. In this case, aerothermal with water pipes is the undisputed champion. It heats the home healthily and, using reversible machines, can circulate cold water to cool the house in summer without annoying draughts. Do not forget to look at the thermal and acoustic insulation in the renovation of the building envelope as well. There is little point in having the best invisible heating technology if the heat produced escapes through badly sealed windows.
Recommended tips and resources for your renovation
Before renovating floors and installations, we recommend reviewing the following detailed articles from our technical office:
- What is underfloor heating and how does it really work in your home? Our detailed technical introduction.
- Microcement in Barcelona: price and application guide A minimalist finish that suits underfloor heating thanks to its thinness.
- Find out the common renovation mistakes and how to avoid them Simple tips from our architects to prevent unexpected delays on site.
Frequently asked questions about underfloor heating
What is the minimum height for water underfloor heating?
A classic system needs between 7 and 10 centimetres of the floor build-up. However, there are now slim-profile panels that take up only 2 centimetres of total installed height. These systems allow the levelling mortar to be laid in minimal layers, which suits the requirements common in older renovations.
Is wood flooring compatible with underfloor heating?
It is compatible if professional installation guidelines are followed. Use stable multilayer timber, making sure the resistance of the whole assembly never exceeds the limit of 0.15 m²K/W. It is also essential to bond the boards firmly to the cement base using special conductive adhesives.
Does electric underfloor heating use a lot of energy day to day?
Direct electric consumption is very high if you heat a whole flat. Because there are no pumps to multiply the thermal output, every watt of heat drawn from the grid is paid for in a straight line. It is sensible to keep this option as a supplementary heat for small areas used occasionally.
How long does a home with underfloor heating take to warm up?
Traditional water circuits have thermal inertia and need between 12 and 24 hours to reach the comfort temperature you want. Electric mats under the tiles, on the other hand, respond quickly and give off a pleasant warmth in the room just one or two hours after you switch them on manually.
Keep reading
Solar panels and self-consumption at home: savings and feasibility
A 2026 guide to home solar self-consumption: technical feasibility, installation costs, payback time and income tax deductions of up to 40%.
Energy efficiencyWhat is a thermal break (RPT)?
What a thermal break (RPT) is, how the polyamide strip in aluminium window frames works and why it matters for your renovation in 2026.
Energy efficiencyWhat is the ICAEN?
What the ICAEN (Catalan Energy Institute) is, what it does in the energy certificate register and how it affects your renovation.

